2019 Award Recipients: Shanyce L. Campbell University of California, Irvine Matthew Ronfeldt University of Michigan
Shanyce L. Campbell & Matthew Ronfeldt. (2018). “Observational Evaluation of Teachers: Measuring More Than We Bargained For?” American Educational Research Journal, 55(6), 1233-1267
The authors’ secondary analysis of data from the Measures of Effective Teaching Project investigates whether observation-based ratings represent an equitable means of assessing teacher quality. Drawing on research questioning the properties of value-added measures and critiques of observations as a means to assess teacher quality, they contribute to accumulating research indicating that teacher observation ratings may measure factors outside teachers’ performance, including teachers’ gender and the kinds of students they are assigned. The study is timely, creatively crafted, methodologically rigorous, and far-reaching in its potential to influence teaching-quality policy and research, while remaining anchored in concern for advancing students’ learning.
This award is in recognition of the lifelong achievement of Palmer O. Johnson as a dedicated educator, and further in recognition of his pioneer work in educational research and methodology. His former colleagues and students founded this award to be given for an outstanding article appearing in an AERA-sponsored publication. It was first awarded in 1967 for an article appearing in the American Educational Research Journal. In 2000, the scope of articles eligible for the award was expanded to include those published in the American Educational Research Journal, the Journal for Educational and Behavioral Statistics, Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, and Educational Researcher.
2018 - Sarah Dryden-Peterson, Negin Dahya, Elizabeth Adelman 2017 - Katharine M. Broton 2017 - Sara Goldrick-Rab 2017 - James Benson 2016 - James D. Anderson 2015 - Matthew A. Kraft 2015 - John P. Papay 2014 - Liliana Garces 2013 - Andrew Ho and Sean F. Reardon 2012 - Alfredo J. Artiles 2011 - Luis C. Moll 2010 - Arnetha F. Ball 2009 - Mark C. Long & Marta Tienda 2008 - Geoffrey D. Borman, Robert E. Slavin, Alan C. K. Cheung, Anne M. Chamberlain, Nancy A. Madden, and Bette Chambers 2007 - Ray McDermott, Shelley Goldman, & Hervé Varenne 2006 - Cynthia Coburn 2005 - Kevin G. Welner & Haggai Kupermintz 2004 - Deborah Loewenberg Ball, David K. Cohen & Stephen W. Raudenbush 2003 - Fred M. Newman, BetsAnn Smith, Elaine Allensworth & Anthony S. Bryk 2002 - Barbara Nye, Larry V. Hedges & Spyros Konstantopoulos 2001 - Joseph Kahne & Kim Bailey 2000 - Ron Avi Astor, Heather Ann Meyer & William J. Behre 1999 - Robert J. Sternberg 1998 - Douglas Fuchs, Lynn Fuchs, Patricia Mathes & Deborah Simmons 1997 - Jeannie Oakes & Gretchen Guiton 1996 - Gloria Ladson-Billings 1995 - Bernard Weiner 1994 - Lorrie Shepard 1993 - John Smyth 1992 - Linda F. Winfield 1991 - Yeow Meng Thum & Anthony S. Bryk 1990 - Richard Murnane, Judith D. Singer & John B. Willett 1989 - Gaea Leinhardt & Ralph Putnam 1988 - Robert B. Slavin 1987 - Edward H. Haertel 1986 - Henry I. Braun & Ted H. Szatrowski 1985 - Bruce D. Spencer 1984 - Kenneth D. Hopkins 1983 - Jere Brophy 1982 - John R. Bergan 1981 - Joseph T. Lawton & Susan K. Wanska 1980 - Penelope L. Peterson & Christopher M. Clark 1979 - Richard C. Anderson, Ralph E. Reynolds, Diane L. Schallert & Ernest T. Goetz 1978 - No Award Given 1977 - Pinchas Tamir 1976 - Kenneth O. Doyle, Jr. & Susan E. Whitely 1975 - No Award Given 1974 - Richard C. Anderson & Raymond Kulhavy 1973 - Joel R. Levin, William D. Rohwer, Jr., T. Anne Cleary & Paul A. Games 1972 - Leonard Marascuilo & Joel R. Levin 1971 - Janet D. Elashoff, Gene V. Glass, Ralph A. Hakstian, Tse-Chi Hsu & Leonard S. Feldt 1970 - Gene V. Glass & Glenn H. Bracht 1969 - James G. Holland 1968 - Wells Hively II 1967 - Patrick Suppes & Elliot W. Eisner