November 20, 2026
Dear AERA Community,
I am writing with another update on AERA’s ongoing challenge to last year’s unprecedented cuts to the Institute of Education Sciences (IES). As you may recall from our last update earlier this year, our legal team filed a motion for summary judgment seeking to reverse these actions and require IES to fulfill its critical, congressionally mandated mission in leading and funding education research and statistics. Many of you played a critical role in supporting that filing by submitting powerful and important statements to the court documenting and substantiating the harm caused by the Department of Education’s actions.
Last week, the United States District Court for the District of Maryland held a hearing on the motions filed by AERA and the administration earlier this year. We are disappointed to report that this week, the court ruled in favor of the administration. While we knew many aspects of this case would be an uphill battle, we are still deeply disappointed with this outcome. Importantly, the court did not rule that the actions taken by the administration were lawful. Instead, the court ruled against us on an aspect of standing called “redressability,” finding it lacked the authority to remedy the harms that plaintiffs faced. In ruling this way, the court did not reach the question of whether the administration’s actions were lawful.
However, the court did recognize that the administration has “severely hampered the agency’s capacity to fulfill its various statutory duties,” and concluded that the “paper-thin” explanation for its decisions regarding the mass terminations of contracts and staff at IES left the court “struggling to understand exactly how the Government made its determinations that certain contracts and entire sections of IES should be terminated.”
As we’ve conveyed previously, we believe our collective pressure is making a difference. This lawsuit, other legal challenges, the powerful statements submitted by members of our community, and sustained public advocacy have contributed to steps the Department has taken over the last year to restore some functions at IES and to spend appropriated funds. The court’s decision is disappointing but does not erase that progress or diminish the importance of continuing to speak out. It also underscores the difficulty of securing judicial remedies for harms caused by abrupt, severe, and far-reaching agency decisions.
We are in touch with our legal team and assessing potential next steps. So many of you have bravely contributed to the effort to fight the efforts to decimate IES, and we are deeply grateful for your work, contributions, and courage. Despite this decision, YOU HAVE MADE A REAL IMPACT.
I am so proud of our AERA community, and our AERA central team and I remain honored to stand with and fight for you to support and protect researchers and the knowledge they produce that helps improve our society and the world.
Towards justice,
Tabbye Chavous, PhD Executive Director American Education Research Association