NSF Updates: Senate Funding Bill Rejects Proposed Cuts, Lawsuit Challenges SBE Dismantling
NSF Updates: Senate Funding Bill Rejects Proposed Cuts, Lawsuit Challenges SBE Dismantling
 
Print

November 2026

Three developments in November could have significant implications for the National Science Foundation (NSF): a Senate funding bill that rejects proposed cuts and supports the Social, Behavioral, and Economic (SBE) Directorate; a lawsuit challenging efforts to dismantle SBE; and Senate consideration of a new NSF director.

Senate FY 2027 Funding Bill Rejects Proposed Cuts to NSF and Supports SBE Directorate

On November 12, the Senate Appropriations Committee released five FY 2027 appropriations bills, including the Commerce, Justice, Science (CJS) bill that funds NSF. The bill would provide $8.83 billion for NSF, $80 million above the FY 2026 level. It would maintain funding for the STEM Education (EDU) Directorate at the FY 2026 level and increase the Research and Related Activities (R&RA) account, which supports NSF’s other research directorates, by $66 million.

In addition to rejecting the deep cuts proposed in the president’s budget request, the committee report strongly opposes the administration’s efforts to dismantle the NSF SBE Directorate. The administration proposed eliminating SBE in its FY 2027 budget request,  which has taken steps toward its closure.

“The Committee supports the SBE Directorate and rejects the proposed termination,” the report states. It recognizes the importance of SBE-funded research in addressing public health, national security, education, and interactions between humans and technology, and calls on NSF to continue SBE programs and refrain from steps to close the directorate.

The Senate bill would also retain EDU as a separate budget account, rather than moving it into the R&RA account as proposed in the president’s budget request and the House FY 2027 CJS bill. The committee report language for the EDU Directorate expresses continued support and includes allocations for several NSF programs that seek to broaden participation in STEM, including three programs that the Department of Justice deemed unconstitutional in August: Improving Undergraduate STEM Education: Hispanic-Serving Institutions; Alliances for Graduate Education and the Professoriate; and Louis Stokes Alliances for Minority Participation.

Federal agencies are operating under a continuing resolution that expires on December 11. Details on the Senate FY 2027 Labor, Health and Human Services, and Education bill and proposals for the Institute of Education Sciences and the National Institutes of Health are included in a separate article in this month’s AERA Highlights.  

Lawsuit Challenges Dismantling of SBE Directorate

On November 9, a group of plaintiffs, led by the Federation of Associations of Behavioral and Brain Sciences (FABBS), filed a lawsuit challenging the administration’s efforts to dismantle SBE. The lawsuit raises questions under the Administrative Procedure Act, including whether NSF can close the directorate without approval of or consultation with the National Science Board; whether Brian Stone, designated to perform the duties of NSF director, has authority to carry out the closure of SBE; and whether the decision to close SBE was arbitrary and capricious.

AERA is a member of FABBS and raised similar concerns about efforts to dismantle SBE.

Senate HELP Committee Vote Pulled for NSF Director Nominee

On November 18, the Senate Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions (HELP) Committee held an executive session hearing to consider several of President Trump’s nominees, including Jim O’Neill for NSF director. During the hearing, HELP Committee Chair Sen. Bill Cassidy (R-LA) pulled the vote for O’Neill given concerns that he and several committee members had about O’Neill’s actions when he served as deputy director of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC).

“As CDC director, he did not do enough to stand up for science,” Cassidy said. He also noted concerns about whether O’Neill’s would bring independent judgment to NSF.

“This time requires leadership and fortitude for standing up for what’s right,” said Cassidy.

Prior to the hearing, members of the scientific community, including AERA, urged the committee to hold a full confirmation hearing to examine O’Neill’s background and to seek assurances about NSF priorities from him.

With the pull of O’Neill’s nomination, the future of NSF leadership remains in question. In addition to the absence of a National Science Board, Stone will be leaving NSF at the end of the year. With the new Congress convening in January, president will need to nominate a new candidate to lead NSF.