Published Online in: Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis October 13, 2022
Kevin C. Bastian, University of North Carolina Sarah Crittenden Fuller, University of North Carolina
While research supports later start times for secondary schools, there is little evidence regarding start times for elementary schools. We address this gap with a statewide examination of elementary schools and a quasi-experimental analysis of an urban district that recently changed its elementary start times. We find that earlier start times predict less sleep for students. Regarding academic outcomes, our estimates are small in magnitude and suggest that earlier elementary start times have near-zero effects. Earlier start times predict a slight increase in absences and modestly higher math scores, especially for traditionally disadvantaged students. In districts that need to stagger start times, it may be advisable for elementary schools to start earlier to accommodate later secondary school start times.
Read the full open-access article
Read the press release: "Research Finds Earlier Start Times Have Little Effect on Elementary School Outcomes"
Video: Co-authors Kevin C. Bastian and Sarah Crittenden Fuller discuss major findings and implications of their research
Study citation: Bastian, K.C, & Fuller, S.C. (2022). Early birds in elementary school? School start times and outcomes for younger students. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis. Prepublished October 13, 2022. https://doi.org/10.3102/01623737221121799.
School bus shift: Cleveland City Schools explain need for change in start times News Channel 9, March 16, 2023
New school start and end times announced for D-20 in the Colorado Springs area KKTV, January 24, 2023
Later School Start Times More Popular, But What Are the Drawbacks? NEA Today, December 1, 2022
Early Elementary School Start Times May Not Harm Kids' Grades U.S. News & World Report, October 18, 2022
Study: Earlier start times have little impact on elementary performance K-12 Dive, October 14, 2022
Earlier School Times Don’t Hurt Elementary Students’ Learning, Research Shows Education Week, October 13, 2022
Early start times OK for elementary schools, study finds EdSource, October 13, 2022
Early Birds in Elementary School? School Start Times and Outcomes for Younger Students