Published Online in: AERA Open December 13, 2023
Lidia Altamura, University of Valencia Cristina Vargas, University of Valencia Ladislao Salmerón, University of Valencia
Previous research has evidenced a strong positive relationship between leisure print reading habits and reading comprehension across the lifespan. The rapid evolution of new forms of leisure digital reading could modify such a relationship. This meta-analysis extends previous research by analyzing the relationship between leisure digital reading habits and reading comprehension. We analyzed 40 effect sizes using multilevel analysis. Data involved 469,564 participants from studies published between 2000 and 2022. The average effect size reflects a small significant effect on reading comprehension (r = .055), which contrasts with the medium size effects found in the literature related to print reading habits and comprehension. This relationship is significantly moderated by the reader’s educational stage. At early stages (primary and middle school) negative relationships are observed between leisure digital reading and text comprehension, while at later stages (high school and university) the relationship turns positive. We highlight the different contributions that reading modalities and technological contexts have on our reading comprehension, especially across the lifespan. In sum, leisure digital reading does not seem to pay off in terms of reading comprehension, at least, as much as traditional print reading does.
Read the full open-access article
Read the press release: "Study: Digital Leisure Reading Does Little to Improve Reading Comprehension for Students"
Video: Co-author Lidia Altamura discusses the findings and implications of the study
Study citation: Altamura, L., Vargas, C., & Salmerón, L. (2023). Do new forms of reading pay off? A meta-analysis on the relationship between leisure digital reading habits and text comprehension. Review of Educational Research. Prepublished December 13, 2023. https://doi.org/10.3102/00346543231216463
The loss of deep reading: How digital texts impact kids’ comprehension skills Big Think, January 10, 2024
Indelible Ink: The Lasting Benefits of Print Media for Reading Comprehension National Endowment for the Arts Blog, January 11, 2024
Opinion: How to grow a young Florida reader — with a book, not a ‘device’ Tampa Bay Times, January 4, 2024
Phones in classrooms aren't our only concerns Toronto Star, January 4, 2024
For improved reading comprehension, print trumps screens Free Malaysia Today, December 27, 2023
Learning via computer or phone is 6-8 times less effective than paper books Lao Dong, December 27, 2023
Study: Reading paper books enhances comprehension skills among children and adult Shorouk News, December 25, 2023
Reading on digital devices doesn’t help kids’ reading comprehension, study finds Yahoo!, December 23, 2023
When it comes to boosting reading comprehension, print rules over screens Forbes India, December 19, 2023
We read better on paper than on screen - The reading research evidence Athens Voice, December 17, 2023
New research shows kids learn better from books over screens Newstalk ZB, December 17, 2023
Scientists have explained which reading format is best perceived by children Glavcom, December 16, 2023
Reading print aids comprehension better than reading on digital screen Al Mayadeen, December 16, 2023
Study: We earn eight times more by reading a book than a digital text Ora de Sibiu, December 16, 2023
Reading print is better for comprehension than screens, study finds Axios, December 15, 2023
Research: We assimilate knowledge better in print than that in the digital text Efsyn.gr, December 15, 2023
Reading print improves comprehension far more than looking at digital text, say researchers The Guardian, December 15, 2023
La lectura digital no ayuda a comprender el texto como la lectura en papel El Mundo, December 15, 2023
La comprensión lectora es menor si se lee en digital que en papel Levante, December 14, 2023
Digital devices stunting kids’ literacy (subscription required) The Australian, December 14, 2023
Playful reading on paper helps understanding more than if it is done through digital media, according to a study Europa Press, December 14, 2023 (Reprinted in El Periodic)
Printed books were more useful than electronic books for children's development - study Tengri News, December 13, 2023
The reason children should read from printed books rather than screens Yahoo! News/The Telegraph, December 13, 2023 (Reprinted in Canada Daily)
Study: Relationship Between Digital Reading, Improved Comprehension Marginal Diverse Issues in Higher Education, December 13, 2023
Reading on digital devices does little to improve reading, study suggests Yahoo! News UK, December 13, 2023 (Reprinted in MSN.com, Express & Star, The Standard, G7)
Printed books prove to be better for children's minds than e-books Gazeta, December 13, 2023 (Reprinted in MKRU Volgograd)
Do New Forms of Reading Pay Off? A Meta-Analysis on the Relationship Between Leisure Digital Reading Habits and Text Comprehension